Which anime list should be official?


#1

Please choose one of the 3 lists below, or indicate if you think none of them should be official. Please note: The mods have not yet decided whether or not to adopt an anime list, and the poll winner will not necessary be adopted. I also created a poll on the Unofficial iCM Forum (see that poll for comparisons between the 3 lists).

Paste’s The 100 Best Anime Movies of All Time (2016)
99 titles on the iCM list (100 on the original list) (ranked)
(this list includes 3 OVA series, 18 films based on series, and 9 shorts)
From an article by Toussaint Egan (Paste Magazine writer) and Jason DeMarco (on-air creative director of Adult Swim and co-creator of Toonami). “A primer of 100 of the most influential and essential films that Japanese animation has produced.”

MyAnimeList’s Top 75 Standalone Films (updated twice a day)
75 titles on the iCM list (ranked)
(this list includes 9 shorts, and no series)
The highest rated standalone anime films on MyAnimeList (the largest anime site, with about 4 million users). The most-rated film on the list has 348,456 ratings, and the least-rated has 427 ratings. The original source includes all anime films, so the non-standalone films were removed, and there will likely be disagreement about which films to include on the iCM list.

100 Anime (BFI Screen Guides) (2005)
115 titles on the iCM list (100 on the original list) (alphabetical)
(this list includes 32 OVA series, 18 TV series, and 7 films based on series)
From a BFI Screen Guides book by Philip Brophy. “An exploration of the wonderfully complex and beautifully disorienting world of Japanese animation - anime.” Not intended as a list of the best anime. See this page for more info.


#2

Vote here:

  • Paste’s The 100 Best Anime Movies of All Time (2016)
  • MyAnimeList’s Top 75 Standalone Films
  • 100 Anime (BFI Screen Guides) (2005)
  • None of these 3

0 voters